This beachfront house sits proudly overlooking Vineyard Sound on what was once a Wampanoag summer camp. Sited on an isolated promontory, the undulating topography rises quickly from the shoreline, embracing this time honored New England home. The interior layout is traditional and finely detailed with is winding staircases and hand scraped oak floors. The Great Room, despite its grandeur, welcomes you with its quarter sawn oak paneling and two opposing rumpfort fireplaces.
Fitting a robustly modern house into an exposed setting, regularly subjected to strong sun and extreme off-season weather, is a unique challenge. The steep roofs, shingled walls and modest glass of traditional New England building are time-tested antidotes to such conditions, but in this case they have been resoundingly rejected in favor of flat or shallow-sloped roofs, sweeping glass walls and unique exterior paneling. The weather is kept at bay with sunscreens, careful detailing, and good materials and workmanship.
Topographical challenges can be the hardest and the most rewarding. This site was in a class by itself, one of the few Island locations with a wide view of both Vineyard Sound and the Atlantic. With great care we carved a building site from the steep, wooded hillside, moving tremendous amounts of earth but retaining many mature trees. High ceilings, full detailing, and sweeping glass walls yielded bright and airy rooms looking out across pool and view avoiding the “glorified basement” feel that plagues lower floors of many hillside houses.
An ancient Native American settlement once occupied this site, and the house resembles shelters built by the Indians who lived there. The “round house” or teepee, with its central fireplace was a typical family home, while the “long house” was a communal building. Many construction details were invented during design and construction to keep this modern-day building true to its inspiration, including the four-sided fireplace, second-story buttressed barrel vaults and the twelve-sided teepee roof that joins a square clerestory.
The challenge was to honor the pastoral nature of the setting and to build a new home that would have the unmistakable feel of a country place that could have existed for a century or more. The Island’s long tradition of common-sense house building played into the siting of the structure, which opts for somewhat more modest views in exchange for shelter from the sometimes tempestuous New England weather.
Unlike most projects we have worked on, this house does not pay homage to an awe-inspiring water view. Instead, it melts without pretense into a pastoral meadow bordered by stone fences, recalling the Island’s roots in farming and sheep herding. Accordingly, this house literally grows out of its site. In places the roofs nearly meet the ground, and except for painted windows and brick chimneys topped with 250-pound clay pots, the exterior is all weathered wood.
Starbuck Neck in Edgartown is now the site of many grand houses, but this was the first “cottage” built there, around 1872. Our renovation, which doubled the size of the house, required the addition of steel reinforcement to old and new portions of the structure for dimensional stability. Original features were carefully preserved and others were added, including narrow side verandas, wind vanes, wainscoting, screen porches, craftsman cabinetry and simple mantles.
Modern and unique, this house sits on the edge of a field overlooking a pastoral landscape. Bold, nearly flat-roofed dormers, large mullioned awning windows, galvanized iron railings and a lead-coated copper chimney adorn the exterior. On the first floor a screened gallery has an enormous movable wall consisting of lead-coated copper construction some forty feet long and a full story high with two large windows, imbedded in the doors. The entire wall is mounted on tracks and, in good weather, can slide away completely to reveal a linear screen porch adjacent to the main living spaces of the house. When this happens, it becomes a house without walls. The interior spaces take full advantage of the south facing orientation. Unusual details abound on the interior to create a contemporary cottage effect. The use of painted horizontal paneling throughout is warm and inviting.
There’s no limit to the creativity of architects or their willingness to challenge a builder. This one-of-a-kind design resists labeling, with its huge cantilevered roof overhang, massive outdoor stone fireplace and endless geometric detail. The biggest challenge, not obvious to the casual eye, was to carve the house into a hillside to preserve the privacy of its setting, obtaining a relatively flat site while still enjoying a stunning 180-degree view. This afforded the additional bonuses of stone retaining walls, terraced plinths, and the creation of outdoor “rooms”.
The Vineyard’s climate, especially in exposed locations, can be hard on summer homes. Our knowledge and experience helps make a house that can withstand and even collaborate with native conditions. The style of this unabashedly modern house was a response to the site, whose view was only marginal at the ground but truly a wonder at the second-floor level. The 24-foot height restriction ruled out a spacious two-story house. The solution was a capacious upper-level sundeck with panoramic vistas of the North Shore and the Elizabeth Islands. Minimalist detailing yields simple forms that offer few opportunities for water to collect and a minimum of surfaces to maintain.